The Pledgettes Talk Real Estate: Lessons from Three Investors

Real estate investing can feel intimidating, especially when you're just starting out or trying to navigate the complexities of property management, taxes, and market fluctuations. But as three members of The Pledgettes recently discussed, jumping in—even imperfectly—can lead to valuable lessons and financial growth.

Getting Started: Three Different Paths In

Every real estate journey begins differently. Jenn entered the market after her parents and older sister purchased a fourplex. She purchased a two-bedroom condo and had a roommate (or was house-hacking). Katy took a different approach, buying a two-bedroom condo as a way to diversify beyond stocks and prove to herself that she could handle property ownership, even while facing ongoing financial challenges.

Stephanie's story started with her then boyfriend (now husband) as she moved into this house with rooms. Their story highlighted the creative financing options available to investors. They leveraged a home equity line of credit (HELOC) to purchase additional properties, demonstrating how existing assets can become stepping stones to building a larger portfolio. Her experience also underscored something every investor learns quickly: real estate transactions are complex, and markets don't always move in your favor.

The group's conversation touched on the reality that property ownership involves more than just mortgage payments. Property taxes, insurance costs, and strategic decisions—like whether to invest in a new roof to potentially reduce insurance premiums—all factor into the equation.

The Escrow Surprise: Managing Monthly Payments

One (very recent) eye-opening part of the discussion came when Jenn shared her monthly mortgage payment jumped 25% after her lender discovered a negative escrow balance of $3,000 combined with increased insurance and taxes. This kind of surprise can strain any budget, and it highlights why you want to include a buffer as you run your numbers.

The group debated the pros and cons of paying property taxes and insurance through escrow versus handling them directly. While escrow provides predictable monthly payments, it doesn't always align perfectly with actual costs—and as Jenn discovered, shortfalls can lead to sudden payment increases.

Jenn is working through her next choices: pay a one-time escrow payment to catch up, refinance (because interest rates are lower than when she initially bought her house), or continue with the higher payments.

Throughout Jenn’s real estate journey, she has a long-term strategy and plans to pay her mortgages off early when and where she can.

Fighting Property Tax Assessments

Property taxes can significantly impact your bottom line, but you don’t need to only accept what the city offers. Katy shared how she successfully challenged her property tax assessment by doing her homework. She compared her unit to similar properties, noting discrepancies in square footage, amenities, and market conditions. This detailed comparison work helped her make a case for a lower assessment.

It was a good practice, and after going through the process once, she’s open to sharing her experiences with others and will have more confidence in the future if she feels that her tax bill is not aligned with the market rate.

Beyond taxes, Jenn emphasized tracking all the costs that historically increase over time: HOA fees, insurance premiums, and property taxes. Keeping careful records and understanding market trends helps investors make informed decisions about when to buy, hold, or sell.

Furnished vs. Unfurnished: Finding Your Rental Strategy

The rental market offers multiple strategies, and Jenn's experience illustrates the tradeoffs involved. She experimented with both unfurnished long-term rentals and furnished short-term rentals and has had the most success with furnished mid-term rentals.

One real-time decision she is making is on a condo. The numbers told part of the story: her furnished rental brought in about $2,800 per month after fees, compared to the market rate of $2,200 for unfurnished. However, the furnished market came with more considerations—HOA restrictions, vacancy risks, more active management requirements, and occasional neighbor disputes. She’s debating whether the extra $600 is worth the additional stress and unpredictability.

This kind of trial and error is common in real estate investing. What works in one market or property type may not work in another, and personal circumstances change over time.

Building Your Support Team

Managing rental properties requires more than just capital—it requires knowledge, systems, and reliable people. Stephanie mentioned using TurboTenant for property management tasks and stressed the importance of building a financial team you can trust.

Jenn highlighted another often-overlooked challenge: dealing with a self-managed HOA. While HOAs can be difficult to work with, having a reliable contractor and handyman makes property maintenance much more manageable.

Katy asked about managing properties remotely, a concern for many investors who don't live near their rentals. Both Jenn and Stephanie shared their experiences with property managers and co-hosting services, which can handle day-to-day operations for owners who can't be physically present.

Local rental laws also came up briefly in the conversation—regulations vary significantly by location and can impact everything from security deposits to eviction procedures.

The Real Lessons

What emerged from The Pledgettes' conversation wasn't a foolproof formula for real estate success, but something more valuable: honest insights into the challenges and rewards of property investing.

Real estate isn't passive income. It requires research, financial planning, problem-solving, and often some uncomfortable learning experiences. But for investors willing to put in the work, it offers diversification, potential appreciation, and the satisfaction of locavesting (keeping your money in your community).

Whether you're considering your first property or managing multiple units, the key takeaways are clear: educate yourself, build a reliable team, track your numbers carefully, and don't be afraid to adjust your strategy when circumstances change.

Looking for spaces to share money experiences, ask questions, and celebrate wins? Join The Pledgettes community! Our members love talking money and are open to meaningful conversations sharing their experiences. Learn more here.